Most candles have a traditional cotton wick, but you may have come across candles with a thin strip of wood running through the centre instead. Light one and you might hear a gentle crackling sound, a little like a miniature log fire.
Wooden wicks certainly look different, but does that make them better than cotton? Not necessarily. Both have their advantages, and the quality of a candle depends on considerably more than the material used for its wick.
What’s the difference between wooden and cotton wicks?
Cotton wicks are generally made from braided fibres that draw melted wax towards the flame. Many are designed to curl slightly as they burn, helping the wick consume itself at an appropriate rate.
Wooden wicks use thin strips of wood, sometimes layered together to improve their burning performance. They tend to produce a flatter, wider-looking flame, although the exact appearance depends on the wick’s design.
Both work on the same basic principle: melted wax travels up the wick and provides fuel for the flame.
Cotton candle wicks
Cotton is the familiar choice, found in everything from small tealights to large scented candles.
There are many different cotton wick designs, each suited to particular candle formulations and container sizes. With the right combination, a cotton wick can provide a steady flame and an even, controlled burn.
They’re also straightforward to maintain. Most cotton wicks should be kept at around 5–6 mm, although the candle maker’s instructions should always take priority.
One thing you might notice is a small mushroom-shaped lump of carbon developing at the tip after burning. This isn’t unusual, although excessive build-up can contribute to smoking and an unstable flame.
Wooden candle wicks
Wooden wicks have become popular partly because of their appearance. A narrow strip of wood rising from the wax gives a candle a simple, contemporary look.
Then there’s the crackle. Certain wooden wicks produce a gentle popping or crackling sound as they burn. It can be lovely on a quiet evening, although not every wooden wick crackles noticeably. Some are designed to burn much more quietly.
Wooden wicks come in different widths, thicknesses and constructions. Some include an additional layer of wood, known as a booster, to help maintain a suitable flame.
They also need a little attention between burns. Once the candle has cooled, loose charred wood should be carefully removed before relighting, following the manufacturer’s instructions.
Wooden wicks are often kept shorter than cotton ones, commonly around 3–5 mm depending on the design. Leaving too much charred material can make a wooden wick difficult to light or cause the flame to go out.
Which wick gives a stronger candle scent?
It’s tempting to assume that a wider wooden flame must release more fragrance, but it isn’t quite that simple.
A candle’s fragrance performance depends on its wax, fragrance formulation, wick and the conditions in which it burns.
Wooden wicks can sometimes produce larger or deeper melt pools than cotton wicks, potentially affecting how fragrance is released. But an oversized wick can also consume wax too quickly, produce soot or cause overheating.
A well-designed cotton-wick candle can have excellent fragrance throw, just as a properly developed wooden-wick candle can.
We’ve explained the subject further in our guide to hot and cold candle throw.
Do wooden wicks burn cleaner or last longer?
You’ll sometimes see claims that wooden wicks produce less soot or that cotton wicks make candles last longer. Neither is a reliable rule.
Soot production and burning time depend on the complete candle design, including how well the wick is matched to the wax, fragrance and container.
A poorly selected wick of either material can cause problems. Conversely, both can produce a controlled burn when they’re correctly matched and tested.
The same caution applies to environmental claims. Wood and cotton can both come from renewable sources, but their environmental impact depends on sourcing, processing and other factors. The wick material alone doesn’t establish whether a candle is environmentally friendly.
So, should you choose a wooden or cotton wick?
If you enjoy the traditional candle flame and want something familiar and uncomplicated, cotton is a perfectly good choice.
If you like the appearance of wood and the possibility of a soft crackling sound, a wooden wick might appeal more.
For anyone making candles, the decision needs a little more thought. Different wicks behave differently with different waxes and fragrances, so proper burn testing is essential. Our guide to choosing a candle wick covers that in more detail.
Ultimately, there’s no need to declare one material the winner. A candle that smells wonderful, burns safely and makes good use of its wax is doing its job, whichever wick happens to be at the centre.
