Choosing the right candle wick can be surprisingly tricky. You might have the perfect jar, a fragrance you love and a wax that’s easy to work with, only to discover that your finished candle produces a tiny flame, burns down the middle or leaves black soot around the glass.
More often than not, the wick is one of the first things worth investigating.
A candle wick does much more than hold a flame. It draws melted wax upwards, allowing it to vaporise and burn. Finding the right wick means getting that process balanced with the size of your candle and the ingredients you’re using.
How do you choose the right candle wick?
There isn’t one wick that works with every candle. Even two candles poured into identical jars can need different wicks if their wax or fragrance formulations are different.
When choosing a starting point, there are three particularly important things to consider.
1. The diameter of your candle jar
For container candles, the internal diameter of the jar is one of the most useful measurements when selecting a wick.
A wider candle generally needs more heat to melt the wax across its surface, which may mean using a different wick size or, in some cases, multiple wicks.
Jar height and shape matter too, particularly as the candle burns further down and heat behaves differently inside the container.
Measure the inside of your jar rather than relying entirely on its advertised capacity. Two containers holding 200 ml can have very different shapes and require different wick arrangements.
2. The type of wax
Different candle waxes have different melting and burning characteristics, which affect how they interact with a wick.
A wick that performs well in one formulation might produce a weak flame or excessive heat in another.
This is why candle suppliers often recommend particular wick series for specific waxes. Those recommendations are useful when you’re starting out, but they still need testing in your finished candle.
3. Fragrance oils and other ingredients
Adding fragrance can change how a candle burns, sometimes quite noticeably.
Two fragrance oils used at the same concentration may behave differently with the same wax and wick. Colourants and other additives can influence performance too.
It’s therefore important to test your wick with the actual fragrance and concentration you intend to use, rather than assuming a successful unscented candle will behave identically once fragrance is added.
How can you tell if a candle wick is too small?
A wick that’s too small may struggle to produce enough heat to melt the surrounding wax properly.
You might notice a consistently small flame, a narrow melt pool or a candle that gradually burns down through the centre, leaving thick walls of unused wax.
This is commonly known as tunnelling.
However, don’t judge a wick entirely on the first burn. Some candles naturally leave a little unmelted wax around the edges during their early burns, which may disappear as the candle is used.
Our article on candle melt pools explains what to look for.
What happens if a candle wick is too large?
Going too far in the other direction can create a different set of problems.
An oversized wick may produce an excessively tall flame, consume wax too quickly and cause the container to become dangerously hot.
Other warning signs include persistent smoking, heavy soot deposits or an unusually deep pool of melted wax.
A little carbon build-up on a wick isn’t automatically a fault, but repeated excessive mushrooming combined with a large, unstable flame is worth investigating.
If a candle shows signs of unsafe burning, extinguish it and allow it to cool. Don’t continue burning it simply to see whether the problem improves.
How to test different candle wicks
The most reliable way to choose a wick is to make several test candles using the same jar, wax and fragrance, but different wick sizes.
A supplier’s wick guide can help narrow down the options. Rather than buying dozens of unrelated wicks, start with the recommended size and a couple of nearby alternatives within the same series.
Once the candles have cured according to the wax manufacturer’s guidance, carry out controlled burn tests.
Pay attention to:
- Flame behaviour: Is the flame reasonably steady, without excessive flickering or smoking?
- Melt pool: Is the wax melting at an appropriate rate without becoming excessively deep?
- Container temperature: Is the candle showing signs of overheating?
- Soot and carbon build-up: Are there persistent signs of incomplete combustion or excessive mushrooming?
- Performance over time: Does the candle continue burning properly as the wax level gets lower?
Always test on a stable, heat-resistant surface, keep candles attended and follow the appropriate maximum burning times.
One particularly important point is to test the candle throughout its usable life. A wick that performs beautifully during the first few burns may become too hot as the wax level drops further into the jar.
Keep notes for each test. Recording the wick size, burn duration, flame behaviour and melt pool development makes comparing results much easier than relying on memory.
Are cotton or wooden candle wicks better?
Both can work well when they’re correctly matched to the candle.
Cotton wicks are available in numerous constructions and sizes, while wooden wicks offer a different appearance and burning behaviour. Some wooden varieties also produce the gentle crackling sound that people enjoy.
Neither is automatically better. The right choice depends on the candle you’re making and the results you want to achieve.
For a closer comparison, read our guide to cotton versus wooden candle wicks.
Choosing a wick can involve a fair bit of trial and error, but it’s time well spent. Finding one that works consistently is far more important than choosing the biggest flame, the fastest melt pool or the most attractive-looking wick.
After all, a good candle should do more than smell lovely before you light it. It needs to burn properly too.
